Is Moriarty the Patriot Worth Reading? Review & Where to Read

Quick facts
Format	Manga (shōnen), 11 chapters, 3 volumes
Run	2016–present · ongoing
Community score	AniList 8.3 · MAL 7.3 · MangaUpdates 5.7
Content	Violence, murder
Where to read	VIZ — official

Overview

Moriarty the Patriot, written by Ryosuke Takeuchi and drawn by Hikaru Miyoshi, takes Sherlock Holmes's greatest enemy and makes him the hero. William James Moriarty is a brilliant commoner adopted into an aristocratic family in Victorian Britain, a country rotted through by a rigid class system where the nobility can do whatever they like to those below them. Sickened by that injustice, Moriarty becomes a secret "crime consultant," orchestrating the downfall — often the death — of cruel, untouchable aristocrats, all in service of a grand plan to burn down the old order and remake society. Eventually his schemes draw the attention of a certain consulting detective, and the legendary rivalry begins, recast from the criminal's point of view.

It's a stylish, confident reimagining of the Holmes mythos, and for the most part it's a blast.

What it does well

The premise carries it. Flipping Moriarty from shadowy villain to charismatic mastermind is a genuinely fun idea, and the series leans into it — watching him and his crew engineer elaborate, theatrical schemes against people who richly deserve it has a real crowd-pleasing pull. When the plotting clicks, it's the good kind of clever.

It's also beautiful. Hikaru Miyoshi's art is a major draw, with elegant character designs, sharp Victorian fashion, and a London that feels appropriately gothic and grand. The whole thing has a polished, theatrical look that suits its larger-than-life cast.

And it plays smartly with its source material. Familiar names and cases from the Holmes canon get reworked into Moriarty's world, and the eventual cat-and-mouse with Sherlock himself gives the series a strong central rivalry once it arrives. If you know the originals, the remixing is a treat; if you don't, the charismatic cast still carries you.

Where it falls short

The biggest issue is the moral logic. The series frames cold-blooded murder as a justified tool for social reform, and it romanticizes that pretty hard. If you don't think too much about it, it works as stylish wish-fulfillment; if you do, the "heroic killer" framing starts to feel simplistic or uncomfortable, and the story rarely challenges its own hero as much as it could.

The structure is the other weak spot. Early on it's fairly episodic and formulaic — a vile noble does something monstrous, Moriarty arranges their comeuppance, repeat — before the larger plot gathers steam. And because the schemes almost always go exactly to plan, this is more a story of style and inevitability than airtight mystery; don't come expecting puzzles you could solve yourself.

Verdict

Moriarty the Patriot is a slick, great-looking, very entertaining spin on Sherlock Holmes, anchored by a magnetic antihero and gorgeous art. If you want a stylish Victorian crime thriller and you can take its murder-for-justice premise as fantasy rather than philosophy, it's a really good time. If you want tight mysteries or a story that interrogates its hero's ethics, it'll leave you wanting. Come for the schemes, the style, and the Holmes rivalry, and enjoy it for the confident piece of pulp it is.